I went to a Shabbat service this morning at a wealthy suburban Conservative Jewish synagogue to celebrate a friends' daughter's bat mitzvah.
The rabbi started his sermon with several minutes of praise for the fact that #Israel had just started a war with #Iran.
The best part, according to the rabbi, was that the IDF's preemptive offensive strikes had, miraculously, harmed only their intended targets. According to him, there were no civilian casualties whatsoever. A Friday the 13th miracle!
The rabbi started his sermon with several minutes of praise for the fact that #Israel had just started a war with #Iran.
The best part, according to the rabbi, was that the IDF's preemptive offensive strikes had, miraculously, harmed only their intended targets. According to him, there were no civilian casualties whatsoever. A Friday the 13th miracle!
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •I did eventually mumble to myself, "I can't listen to any more this," and stand up and walk out, but it took a bit longer than it should have.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •The rabbi described how lots are cast on the goats. One of them is chosen "for God" and the other "for Azazel."
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •My friends, for those of you who don't realize, I am afraid I must explain to you the extraordinary, comprehensive ignorance of his statement.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •Mishnah Yoma 6:4-6
www.sefaria.orgJonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •This is not obscure knowledge. It's in the freaking mishna, which is a foundational text that anyone calling themselves a rabbi should be embarrassed not to be intimately familiar with.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •The two goats story he told (and got wrong) was somehow linked back to Jews' obligation to support Israel, though it's not clear to me how (and I think it might also have been unclear to the people who actually heard the sermon).
He apparently also talked about what happened to Jews in Europe before and during the Holocaust, because of course any sermon that lionizes Israel has to be grounded in Holocaust victimhood.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •Don't try to make it make sense, you can't.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •If you don't fucking want people to associate being Jewish with supporting Israel's actions, then don't fucking stand up on the pulpit of a synagogue as its spiritual leader on a Saturday morning and give a sermon in which you gleefully praise Israel for going to war and say Jews are obligated to support Israel even if they die for it.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •The kids are alright, and most of them have no patience for this bullshit.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •Because I'll be damned if I will attend a service presided over by a "rabbi" who gleefully praises war without offering even a token acknowledgment that hey, war is bad, and we would really rather not have to fight wars, actually, and there are human beings on both sides of any war, and killing people is kind of bad, actually.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •*sigh*
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •My concern is with the jingoistic war-mongering and fealty to Israel displayed by this rabbi and other Jewish leaders.
Jonathan Kamens 86 47
in reply to Jonathan Kamens 86 47 • • •